{_H8?"VjA|ڻj뷫moH @ *SI޿B2|q<ƥ/\Wȭ j {n03?I!з=8<ꄣ_a?u0H 7 nn7pơ͍TqO:Tc<ˆ~%|Dq7t#F=Ýܺ˙pl?`؏ܩ`τkOguA;7_Izw+;89ܥ?M+f_{aiN'Z݇wx p.ph v¾,c\>jY|uހnOo/֓_/z),|$e?ORi'88͟)e}Wk Lyn︟OF?;ۧ]_Nv .`4d-k! I+L}[yt]@ ޙ,.TV~ 6,ijsv#gK bDFAg\Og/qo|a9oɑ%鰾CՏ@Ϸzm .9۩?{zᝲs|[7Nœs^`\6 Yc(T~=vocv?@={:msy%:Gd&B\p{{ 6S=NqDK%x;PީzCV-û.9f:̣KWi/Jߞ˝IȇKeyqru xce^C㣝{t+݉;;;?w{qsrtG9Α[ZXVԸqmx+ h -Nn@)'O'Q~|{&ENvȧ)Nn96=+{ɵsgyslݣv>9ݽW2@b8P7ve=Taӷ3Tݹ+|s)Hޑs|g7:>ޕv/ݏ'Gx7s-uN=trпyU3ߗ88p?g NBBJYI^ޜvwyW2厎Sx$G巫R<<}^Wԛ/l_ʗ6vy1Q OA_zhى4߳&$8`My{nb!x >? ^ꛚMp6Ҹ;yv`U!O@݄EJhw80}=o" >{N!_?;r2H">MsȨ^x䏸)Aɓb(u) Yû?\t7,<@N@ᕕ@" %tKAՏې鲒bD@Gu?=)`Gqxzs|xN-P@0 ors !_T3ss~ H'`&ˌ`Wxz=7f4+3=G"QG/0=0$4 -5. oNwsPA<=1AHF}>~ gڦЧ^26Q䐂KVpE,h*'_Ryw3 IزU'S\޽OCpA?ܯCedn,f$N:B50fMZObhW??\ #{TI{d2(<'r-rM y$ m8M ӷڹ8߹<-qTL`"v4Oh{H1N֓yJ`e=ɣd6 33u_Oo6KX g ]/yv&lv["p\!7z?*nR)'eG|#0+k~,S|'C`5;DK%gp:F>~^}۹V- r(N H  F0YJ $J7OaQm]8D>ضLڔ-Cy` 0Dً&"GxVy #DxB2]eхD5.nυ⧛X`!:`M5"gdAZ?=-jPȀjûA6przxRHFح6֫Zx~~z^?9jmh&T'FL> KœÞ.T>& !%cSiwfs4_RFLVx*MwFhvM(*4:#̵p tfSv~ҧů)SJ&Wobt?n _V[YRpil-!_wuĈ(Ӊֻ]Ъ}h~d~QQQk'DO9>2QwDnt_GTDrPАG{]kr2ۻS(t99S $FpEb:!5cҚ:ʫNkӸ_PٜC&*jV ~OTK*(@6y&pSH $&(Wˆ2֏euiij3ZMU;ՌİwkP▴@~;&nSBR~HDCð#j0{x6Þ7=sp_hkx'7=۾N>ݳу䫍P\#n&/{+l ޖgH'5y׻/@Ce7)#^ushHASbB6@:wtHa-b]d߇/_ z{y/πZ맞pё,3y0P0{xhOwp \d9mv%[ieڲ .7+<}J'>1O Փ{< 99 >ƛ)w*2-5@$6YB>N2GreRLғU'&,@P6pek,f2y' ӕ/6%d|D,Del RI} ~3?9ǔMDY~+x`JA)o"g&NɉR1*F=5XB/8.Xs#@V83pΘEl(j y߮&_[?~~tNQ z:{nHxWtaRUS}0x Lh*2tcQ;h;*V-!*Zu>~}˓.,"ffCza 7Y2Y짐ɜ=9 @!s@Zг #){M-Ѐh9"kN S0 j(6Q_KQw*Q_( ,+="b}BLʣ𤋮|?}P nPkKA.Dlt?apwlRe`.:׀_?Y-/Xh\i{. O z*NWïoBCנo?sCŖ1>W|:}(oMrQUoBûOzٛ/;wwN7 w7OvsyORQmQX]?•杩OWûd̶޽m,即>> ςO'­x-k eL7Jm[l;]|z}JO9^ʢ>?4aqcouW=|R?7NoNnd|y&4w{9?-6YRm./zxFnnH;Nmg'>;ggW9ŝcwHʮqֿhlwT..iY[U9x} rx#xD'gwvjboGo/{*oo onԓ?w_?ޟ<EQ^ysrZ[|o;Z[}=ս,.?{ݻ9<ƷW;;ˋ_oYxgc8_GT ?.Ow|ݻ= w*պ(ySy}W?m*;5-hUyߗ qߺua M;Yãow@gSwgG~V8"W?~:^_,|WÇw?~^x?_WnU{`bm\L77?~m}UA_|z;n׳toT٩:߿>͝::轝ˍd~'tq{z$UNjGoˉ~1pԸ>|;|rlޅ{_̾?^X۷;9~>/끼xx\{Co{ﻇpzcpvu~LuqqgMzj_>mOϥ*הp6ޭ{zw*ҽǛ/4<չ^p'WCR9>nqU_uӉn|yC^ğýuG_?>Gӫ͏gʠ~/-NHon}zy|z#|ͽ OOoOwÃt!§:8eJ8홵W7sx+0Zѓwۭq~H Ez<ů@0ozw7g_Wߞ9y3x_w꛰^~Iu9ߞ:巳7_.wmy~5bxqy>}}yrVvuYݫCOz~xne;˲zY*yJ\vaS[_>}:l\%iy~y;ХΞƞx%Y}Ok'O˯eZ*} a+O>WoVg]7vm/*Vy{Y]yǒKBؕ}Ev|}ׯY^!޼W՛c0Og]Ai5<7\9$G/kmNxc*LJww!ֿݝصq]?gm̴w$^|q~7 _WǗ,f ԅjw;$_+gO<NOessvg_yq<<^eZ9:n..;/3>9RΪһ{]Wrؑwo^JԷ7~Ǎsv^}oǽ7>OOoozr> ~-k39ˣ}s7iO/}$͎շYej1¦jYpOSxK9.)stڈrHBVJ⏒Z74 ;Gdl䁓2&MfP̪q͍#y9.Jl\G?o軴A1!@V"[jO-z͜c0͂1MR( g󓛴Po)X6ueuK~&=hD.m^՛4U%>,:MpT|=UoѮ~'&)lC'k,US *fUɧ(g,gW;ˌΉ)Oj}@OEBBW]LXi/,ї:ppqV 4 $ G}#'y U>;E m-[@l2㥦g(/VЯT.~%d ¦R7ogWi, WR\}NbP^fE(@c1,EG`>ܯ sg^ۢ`l g?N__abN:_⽈W[/vcQ*nNԁQXۀs#0Л!wB, *Ԇȁao9|B;_|~_*J]Z54!{J$̳z.fX3% B3P/g#KNFk2]HbC̼9a,n=,\DN`-?L g/'`\Oa6x$S(YaXEݿ9 Y_ ׺4A b3LDP% :BuhvJlw?d-6Xy^\{80yk ߅dZ,|#1,`N(L nѦOx R/WPEicWDU }hl)" clؘpQ8V6/ Y٢m.; nL,Ş?3Y4×7Xgͻ0RKH)tJLTܞ/3l"z,X4a`dۣ(N_w>L)?&vp}7ZOaQ?(+4Gs#5[@9ؑ9\v} Z!&t:X}w0yxHj"9|9Xm!A)YZ TD2ĥ %`Ԩkj~]. ʪVȝQ ؤA`(^tmőnwss h/C=/k??_ϫSkc93\iϼv6xx}Vws>K | >%|&_ϛ#LJg( |kgMO5pwcOg`y'zl G >Gp 6{|' Ogu7=*fiց.X7ګѠ|\@l^WZ{f2&vh=4r/J{(mi)^_T-'m4;)(Q QݝFk8u7T ki-D]NhZ)GT[9}vh;4A׈67o$s)$E,؁dňioՇ9ꂣ Z`{x>!7#8 { ڌӒFRZ}#x!q e$@H8,k7UZf#;"VL6Il w9(kQg4,hmxMd@j4MTgGqOaض`nѼ/GvuO?7]5ʾ#GRY} ,td L6YȃCɤBJVZtI!U}蹳܎!#-R2]U3De;|9{gڏ0r{l"EPFPSwH) B% (h4kT!!,YGtmd3cc5GsES? b#^|ϿL_74NI37ժ׵; 5o a7V&! &EPW^@7%n(\[${Z :6|j0Kl"G3a6n4m cj$Đ1H10>!ds_؎f>܄Zvy3L+6Q~JdphF WTKɊ/ > ,NOR_}ևV}X"j.#9+7amI̬!F/,.eV {_̈́ldJm6FVLlB; qȂN:gzʆJZm*R煷)c- a _ B%=[8,\&|Z!AeEYs.Gnz#mnNF3C1Z DV"F-#v p9rCU1hpeL?cT5GUQFrE gW`ցV`n:v[sy "R$@q&StߠoQ}+'M&Az`*dӛy躼0GgXtt֭9%FzfmkUD{[RR|82!A,Q0CC˭q+-&3ovb Vߺ ^a:h|Մgw=;_L08r[+Ku94HefB Xuݷ0Uͅ(ۦ?L(5?d}ګQl@Jp)bۧ6{(m*NXgt~Ȃl]XFluiuJ!O/f9A{n1W79jc=kR^gq6 /uIٴy&@&2m<b>%a' it3X|6._a$^5C7tM{PJѦ5J9ri㼐JSB\IhwSv%En+I[9U"Ћ=m hK~.veSDҸN+/!iĖ萵h2|A`j/R^9f5Sͨ[v0㦅F@tB8IU`^ %H2j<'z M3EXz&<:LQ3LOMBqI{, :"֥mH{x2Rv!اbď"9Pv~DiٛD \eb%8S"(3xƹP>2Q+aIa X- ^,{ i `IР)K]y1}CAҗ7Nd/4ّ=oMށa|]+\avgtfn*P;Ix`tdXI_m&tJ^q{ډ+,p睗a*qµL"Dtjr?h;|iP$8 P{n]$?w0ya/ avB{nTM%#E jJ8&7K,;Dm`ݾdOw-D!d;NF˔zCm1ѡ da5{so2]w.VZ%t(6]o@N2E~ЫnU A[E)&J8jQ@>k+ϼW`f,Wv'C+ۑoސ FVK >r畼U HQN{ݾ4{t](}.҃@v=)E,%; TY0o&O   U5x/>W|鱑B.& ~A}Q3 HdžبRI`kxs5I^h τ:0~LgW!˳jFytNVc0쾲%}P-!B3P\'+LSY~Uq20t`u[Ț8ʜ̬ f %dc- QsQ^b7U(0vZE Hx6M, '8v/*5n P`2)A3 堣,E2kCL)cз#sL[}I'17jV'ȭP!ho r;k/KtRHh)D0Ηd@D( M-_7JT5oIhiWjW̐p9q?y!B-ޢHn!zwȻRH~UAEVDZoys}`ع )%KvT~N;pc Z$JǷ>pẎv4kL_&=h"2ڄD0W-JbUGbfp)Utg=jhHNPQõָ lx2Li" MH yjfP^p8n IWrd02|Јf9 tdÛY|DT Gj Uk]uBHfl\F=ERaARX.=j@J܀k/RBdG! mCf,T fM7Dn(|~T3:0TL@t̴m؂8 ~(zfS`T;Q͚ >R+<f"9tg`}L7g#MLA]ymJD 3+uqk`Pf")jjزci,[Ϧ(=kfydjfZ৬I3#;z@p9h3<7GyD ߯:> .%QƒK֔F;o"D *&"53QWxSe0y)pή$Bڦy;oJ hTgtz#UoV7q^KK<@뎫MIJǐaQAH-I4*DHbk%I-$4&)|c*'v$p@%E4zM & ,&J C؟zBadšǽT ݲڋ}ʁL6&f-"[DUDJ…BT NsjqR %ŽL(SǵY \[D˾鑊*p]@ ;GK\ h*ҁR -@l*抬Wәw̍y8WVdQ 0.&Md*ܑ ui5|ecB&gAk"<  n;j"i5-)q-¹aPYd4."'Q{T+:M,&4ri"i\jrfI9ip +ʁ))u$2B3 PW^mkhOGz67]摧gs'*:7 5@ >/4¯רΪi n;XQ3p蚞KHіɢZCeLcBAEhBWo S;%"({iO 53>|"~ k_wTdU)]mj&BV?4|<@]N5! cJ?%)|Mp>\ ⃂yАiDS[ᗇbD?\&yP@#71%t`um4zNH${ T-hsy FNiOaAخ[L3 UEjVuЭE&䤚ŝQg<\VWr~bKՐ sn2kV1c [X"O[’e@qîѝʓ`1Z 3[Wʞ"Y+Ggaj}*&!B߫ZI{k7脎k׌*-3舨$#t3j#[6 t6-{Z[v@[_vr [뛇団7R5|៥b>f,,a׾}DiKҁIʋ5wZ! ;s(DGt,q+ݟH z"$3T4rЅPQd Uk [XFPe`x[WfX\CpO^Q!goJCn5 kQFwe[KP^Xut)m9Y+MJ>iUۣD 74͉8{I` ;,{R;D\3F5gRI&鏚JV?mrLقOb+jZ[멋h.  /qL&ؘ!\LFNFR8.,7AS CgfSFˁ@K \qi-D4FqP3h/޵2Y*Qˢ'F‰u4C&aR6+۳ ;Xx7!1g8 Tg W7R9chpHFBH=B/ R?O]=0 l }#wf;N >_C7 UU& !|UTP 譨F i8-ÄN5^W4<-͒@2QIq-R(VMyMJ(&eE,`=H~_fZ8 Aqjf8xKkkd[MYڬozH4 z=wX흖k-zSUT1(暽g@fK 3 ;u-Ni{"B ݸ)Bt~ḭ 6]e{[ELXB]qqǜ?B6,uaÉ,KնBWN:%4gꃝUfcY8ur93fѕD bH^mR G hG 93O+a_F8_xU$SS[&$8([04W5sAj5 0kChZӥ>AxW0[=!%)P=57+H.^>֒,1L>Մ*Fy"mdy*lcJE,&U _i,' P#}* 8?1REF4 8 ,2]>g) BRaE {K"E !gI7-j hTeEXUWWɼt4:9$O^1-lĭg78*e\Ӝ(H%w^ϖ?'%.Pё|1+YM(:A"b-S_l5vkn00Qv1d%8Zh ,r.! ϙF\3/Z3MBp`T"(lӅԑ W uSFy٭k[ԛlj6(Lƾ=7p#$[6Cfܐ4HߟDQ߉TNͿZ~}).;/yXg.;;=ʃE<WC8\!8점:Jq4pAw\ݦa m8 3MMzf6[zwig&Xok^|G\  D N@QvZ/a+0X-l ](f 3{hh )%bgG6Ds2l 5!1GÅRx%Wьi]DàRiirX+oWy_ȚR`$k? O`FN?RH `Bwz'kA p,_r> 0h[ZKSnyzp$0- Ѓ=*7FMG ><[Fm~dy;Zv/4ռ+*FuF2 mmf3"9F0H\yыRRFY,( ŚZ1qe͘qUJnRT-& :GO5?i/SFa<áY!?Jǐ)>7F؂[E=d@t4/ZS3/io" :vǞq!%1J\nQqHwUy" դo_H>E|2虋vhQ yvPD360Z r Gb?evt4ݾcmg ۤ=wzaxbHqHYv|%/I G@DNH7FlT6T4rŤ5(d;{E@ؕra8t¸ːr "E?%b@cL54/:v嫲2)vGd*;ȤXr+ӽ妅B%20p-׀v Gz;l8rCOex|3zPX!0őPYP cOcE<[L{l7XK[$qo??ʁ7jZ*pY[d0n9;Gy-/'x  :ZG'CJe%VçK"K0"CKDBE] `\zX3M쿹&diycܑ{ǬU'q>D6(% x2͑\pXɠsTIpb2R BŽ 舰;?e}5@ 7Þ4u:^Ь0[4^c~f :^7E\)tp[yy9>sƽ颲&_FZ]8')L=uiW?Tm[ W11ܖNP6,1߆Λx)+ijdtݍSQ[&Tp*{M;7-|!KWσVu;_9F+"rQ.Έb &ՈԲ]ljxjQlGs ŐL'4][Z-x: R99ŠEgwf˩VH^25V`FXNMwSvXóur*rwm./ '8+q-.Z E aͻ`jed U'lZjNlvq,A(zKiB0gb0و$Fϒ,c MFg"yNobxٝ[PbrdfS|1: $EH%AKZбzS7 QvEZnw Uu&ywICK,(137sOWՖSJ8^herObrjH/RsUU2RrpѪ]zzM]'S?J[A^ݩH/L2dpc,ut!KZ/ZNWMCxښq`Ґ]MiX㷄S++JY$p4{=3)G)V/HJBm,Q4I:qSbWpCPat‰"!6[lPjwrdAO҂&00GetspLTU.8gqF+ǭb[Ix)n FRbu*g a_[l_Q RoFb)l(]CI訌>tjPj=0nꑹ}1'Cv^E"YK$71x.ǫ$uaH|Ӕ+E!{EQ%|r.xZp|\ݤI_8hBV2[d E"啢.ܩ5EC8ve0>[-ď,4z)2s)s"mI@8+:1|> )BG%^yk *k7q5)M:3d{"w&-nH(DY.uʎb.sjF Q6$\&4AE2Liiۜ %@HAPqiv:5_;Z gH|BbJ#g5K0ZgF9 lP1e(h }M@"RKq(@)ܣJ(Z`pSA  ir_%& ̈ؼij!*=c 'XjRș6s83U qE=*[6`PC/EtSP Ȭ%ޜ1QV N# s T)ZnhhcchRQsaUIxD7 hȵbF׍ZaŠR0J0JFL c&k&8K\[ðh(̔`YF Bۗ-G@\H_T.m-׍P+.4 RyWFM6v'!Ni&7cp=pC(qv[辽^8؎[*cIWck6ϛ4rӬyR,DEn-3nzM'RM1fa9~gJsjFlm}1ZbfάV[j.NtFE`݈x'BEc=ھcE7T0Y< 3L>ߖI`m;}Eꓒg4EET"}zS^u4ylYL:bp>,2Xe3oNy4G*K4)bЙHYIR)g.A׵Q3g=5 9bL vV aW#4ˏ 5`0h%9%k|۽Qk<'a"3j\z9u|Xh}>}wcdJ@2$$a$$nqDB"QE^0?z"3n6IBDe~0iy-63Y}>H]py?Mϫl&ha\*5bZIhx#p1C=,tVz`˼X3MMM}vrX8,TI\Cޕnfz&18O&^ MPֶ@f^R؞UgeIVIhźmgg,-FNBܲE{*rXL,+VYe&,=>`*$Misٌ/vyb*iJv{ʥY -IyE^G*tO2a7CQEČ^I%0hNAS?(n_ ehdlJ|˜[!JL]kdĩ ׽4mǭ`8ƊD8R+\3B;+*- V#T5^! ﳸqZ9uF)jdN c%:,= sO4Fˋ8B_ܔdP#XptCf$E; S@oC;p:#uGċ0 Zv zvFTcvsLѾlhp)\Ԣ*ȥ/d( /&2YfIh |e3yrpͷb# &]^lzWaw8:(@kt>7mߙ̘<<ٳDy1n9WQGX!R `K@{ H aTáHpܱ z$g{8td*;Z呦{0d'6o ؀A$oH9)rn'-7O=' 8U2۴ |fdL!GgtEBNs"9ln?qP_){EnXqr/E֕Hwdj;kd_kY"Wx"Gx^r{1W<yZ.hBlu9H jƢ݁m]F;5yrm)KR#It;DD]A8 WGwpvCc[L ɖP۪*Wif5~vC~|rCC~0|#Z\s,硍)L`%0NAwg{p%lv F9 ,fk "S@E5ѓJ(UV4 gvUHL҃Y8pygWܜ%]^Qߺʨ*b#eYGEyY}:}UHW1[I4dgTM̐JP(yfA]("g c 4u9)*qͽ.c'H'H!_>'7C=g:DwP} ~Tvr*Z;BK\wҸ%JZʮ R!("~M2-n f(AgP!m\YR2+Txو\k?χ ]Lb%da H5)5a]J ГC7ͼg֕_KnnqijjØλmEYxgce{/lu&) *5rfvm*3^`RL4pa v;[(Qd+SHNT+O]jx +7ףH!eMi4=gtP7d֓`Zs7;η|"C`]#mEt~9(aSJ9Ojz"jܒY_GǏF Ed\$sQis-P.Sā T4f5 z-斮GK {PbV4m9X^EsIuVgKoy6޹Lg-J(H LkYޚ|M#RҤ}nf|Sk+Wo"$6_LEkcrcFb#IR_f?~;3 )e!2^"qSR=wd-;jZSc1Ld(g՝-Z 2 %L) +wY|&|TR9.az\d4 7RYu6o[H+:Ԑ|l\i(dLuJb  ,. qBFl !>L]6ʎ.YN#YSLQ- /kKA7.ܸ̙h8 -?J&L^V;ųYBF ay]ް\:!,tyDWHñ7J%*%͖?/a'8elJTPO0ɖSݱ&@-RݝɸKbfO7t>yʛWm#hV[O340=Jg.1ugqYRgN"},?*<9_[9jrTy\5F"r_V0%8H<‰FL+ IJ2FJ(8ͯ,E 0 p*Q<8_<,$dphNE Sɍ"G٘eGz;t.=2m}Y6( )%J( 4DL835Չ#OݨձysGjčZz5S1f*|@5م؉k(&8M3@bNJR/,Hn')QU ~k.N)! ?EăEJ4a~jHeCJ6zϏ>iN@0s;KՌ8$@/M3O\rv̈́W?\n{6wbh[MӭTW4] *A3|(ĤHdjϟ°r.952MKn+" GD 6,xٓFeo4ndd%9ZrahYJnN|˘( poUF V? `\(.N&߄tCF Bln.>L&6,xU8n;y[sGs&R_3% aBM(~QjsGkc1dcB)bQ# MPߪ!09e(Z!;Y⛉fwhΠM%tK Ua*6 ?@26ٺUds,8[Qrh9TEԂAǓJyn(à2, p\-Qmuڣ l4衖o !x+: kFqj@&ZdV(beC[ Tݙ ]^ 2:!Mx:m6:x9-vn]JXʼnks/8 I5s 0 ZFEMÂ2Z)/0ҠbVr$Y0O|QJM#$@d׼iz[HgTEL<vҀ ; ̾KgvQ_WxÂzX)N0j.#'}_2;$cm{sDSޤhvk[T̃E৙1?t]Ŧg6 Ggy*`0jxɤQ{Ҽrݺv_Wr0՚T}W'b=+7/XOn-ۭ83?4%Z̤[ڼ$GOuܹ4YfD`9:8a dXӍr*N[9٩m7%|+X4EF@/q\a !hœdzA[՗ u=Х'jƋh.QH6kG0] .c 8Lh3wX\dԆ0ӠE-*Ku5H|N=TD=a%6pBUw1ѹ樳o8UCoǭ =])dFtJ(OOF(8LIؤ!cAV;ܾ`%]/\p @AţM*_i`F (1Y ! Z,*J4\!qY`,llX)giU:Lۗ-/sLE&,l9ר+5=(0&ͬRFNw8mmg0@:5cԇh=mh8VJj@;g:s#7XY\ˏiRDֽw:h)vրZܐ +G:G E~&2z~ĉȦb4SQ?rX:j{LȗRpdEDu\tzE= !) ~N,b8 K`CjD$5)yXBHGC!@BjV^0E\>9 /;ʭU+e,͚rۘdB33=64cAS3AcXbc=e˖oq8+쑭Ӕ}@D=i0ifj(^mTSOM{^(MnuH:7ʫޟ'EͼTuMJ%Wr:'I~UlIyZ4#o"Q"oPd,M@˵H R{`jm6Ufu~fW\)h t}984"J,qVLI<`|7~yUW\,VIO"0eX M,lUN fe1nMۊ\lRgVAw5"+N^I@JHѨ ]Jm#^J hfKcUL공 6tNgڳCE̙LN ̔~e^_:MRi A0%8bLAR3[ћmB $/ѓx{"wdq4ZXfH(ePV,$0feCFFå 'L;D(qwQdO) LoB(ᱶ/;AqT}٨5Rqm~B#Oiъ_Xf Nc43GY{EU@@'xJA+t> {ҦV8MRnk(%Z~(' 0&_?Ϯ>^8L6 -C.X,*]‚f,4V yI{'RcV0QQY8.a9UFm`z7VS 0أhlweXiR>r2r4e*8uC3ǘtUZP/N4<辘l'ʎvu "dFa; b"貸Uf0*%:K5[\[ !0W{1I([JwrCK^Q@D%,Mlc7&J9+q>-d:_ٸ2]ԒEeW"J9d"$0!Tik鱉a|5!} p:S,ok" qALZjpl:La cOv`֨[ChR\kA-daMLs{Q+ZSmՉ%7=,0b#KprqdZ ̂R'Z~ 8('u4ayI VIH-TbTH2j^Bũdv -;vZI*Jzumʙϼ~{ΆU!Fi2 1$ ;8.D_Km|ZJNԆ)ot9:uWtT&JU" FAg;$_-: #^ -zb4AQhηF4)KU†M6#J0a̶bS4 GP 4D^c/{@_c)wA&I$RɨVӹ֛S7sKl(KX |ȟ zPN@P0&9[XtkֽhwHb5uK ERUR.s9uY$L$W=SouM?5ee{j鈃YF"P!\# ,>7mށ^DߦwxakFѭX7Hd hɂoBS_Kړ[ !o/Н sKGK\a֚q+"k"&}o*RQa"zjۋp R*SLEG$Ӂ %.AٙKS0 Ӥ@-38(۹Tࣩ+ؑ:c6rந ;Gσ{2_Rʦ !G6P1;05bɷeȇوwDq"dg\!fY CL)"zK[IDuz4c^U:}#ɬ~ek60+F屻?і;4?ON &skjbv)ܝ-aR15tDȧZ ޠ/~2B}%WFPW3C R?$gȅi_$; &ް|<[fmI/ԡoV#$o-Oe n{<8AW%VUtG֫o kYC.FMF9QfĹlnUg${ ۱CaJYO&lkvov8( $e%'AnYYd4aJ!DURp;T@SZd.]?ZQԉ|(U&]+ sTa]Ykf"&WC>:SoM|%~w2٩[4 G$/8Jܙu)ˢ"5M+|vVrc&^R$:1IZ1?Eb-0&O4gހzt&b$GV{m͇^Rle[ +*5BN;TSHq1hiѵNi0q,}u "$=WAxwA`E'E ~doKpl]q4 $ш75ED($©%k(tDAr;V}&`YخO[)i[mN/U"Pq6q e$M7ΆlHYo k1ɉs2LqW 5٧Zn>׋Ħ `eaaq̮A_vb9!ZhSϟN[WP2/$55aLG\fVY$ɽm@{p3Z]~"gЫ!֥#In .Q/*Ji',xdc$YPp?87nۨ"]`{)}wC@+|F ϡġӏRr?0\GB /$6v9 B3{eK OpJ,muB \TIneRM,l P>]Vɜ8wý)h`4= uis˖r|N.C`Dw}(Ônaj_U kK{ST7/DD%TA,F펲 [fa{v6f[t*Yf"g+Y4bW}tӍmi+Cl82n(sCL5(~U&}N"KPʰjpe<&B,[jJ!l$O; (!vA^Ed}g:88&ۚKU&9z =f-+kl3 TF k tGQ/%puCT`ꍬ@@Rs˨Etd;iԘ`l"?Ud}>xCc^vr?$gq,vLɌ=ؕ xR/w5܉ GvI")`0&H"HߧT/&VrOVQ42,?MK?PFy,M#͘&W%v dt6a. Rld֨L<רm,n+x8#Grfq&J kJŕ~Ѩ+&(Puz+ 6BЪE"N*#3 ;huN >U6j%҆\ ŽT ڋ}b'KOGl|mj; 8f(濆VŶxHb7TyEIYL2NRM TFF8ꭼaCrwu7$A:#Z+ Qc~H(bѸ4ͷk{nu$3,͢e)^8'SI/$tdʊ +i˩幫Q4C}+垴\";AA~ot-! ({HZYGAWp.܀% ݹ;0 cp;tgm L}LXiӝy pZ@%#eFAm- f8``-ز::6m'*X4HlP+˜ v= m؞{ ,_&KE:@&CiJH+U0w|0'Z\j=d.o/Be޴Eofv}]SdL@>f7/yy+&db,` yOz1<cDCIS8)PNf ZPmcU?7g(mL!/$ntlx?@ٷW^ג ݁7ʱ;l/z=[-&UYNIK1k $|w֡Zﰟrq$I 4o\!ⷌ-=Rޅ}`nS %#*X {* R'bcFJ?@h;la@Ļ[OW槁eQ"OCs+ZG!7~W`]y"Xͭ Et$v4hT L5M,5zފ !&z %r1j/ *ܢS*Y3[VrPxǠaxdREcQ@^ϩ㜃eFv9v̠zROu{˦J,^;ֶkrjD^f\WZE!$ M(=Pd`Ae@\+^(N/g!J{s;`Lb?"!i=1WYK=oncc9 |[=O3:19*\^[5"6)RZjntw].݃]t35ZTmJ' 蘕+#qY,s5^Ubw~PgP\ei^ǚM~'hBvl C'+"%\=-BNbyFoڃq@\{C'^d,IZ?e::J7BBߡ`>FNg7ʇtdPͯGs;pp~rCGtS&[;K`k9kz%@@gD,=,`Wl U#BOxX$3[}91BΓyɄPZp#T`VeA;#s?*E[ Q$؜a_Y+ w/qSL"qVkXfnV#y 7S>  \пĭN( (LSLkB20`LG];Hv<%u 0{nSE\*GlA&t1XѕJf=.00ۜc^uVߘb㖴<7¸ALq:ꪖ_) nM#~YWddmz DTv ;18~90 cImu<i:+ >τO+h ž8YLH69P 7I5&F{Jv M'bO&#3W؍VFa+ݜF%"4&Dx8%үwR"S-PSDbY*J/3ScWQƩtceY.R-nk:^+bN>5p8my9vr-KKa©",1*NYdQ{Su2VGf%}lZNO- J y~K%n܃^ LvZzf Tًw:}07a(FZY:j<}CsvS Q<}+i8xhq^ }@.wNW}w}zIޭaKz5y_nhX-ifkb3bczV iz<[fְozZU)Tyj-F_`ҙ@wXKj tYSoWobϪL8Ī!?/Ir=s2M]iQ[Ǻ'Z8t tx?Zi,2'71GH0?X&&ؒ` # 2aV:bʉ}[Mzfg" WBf;$HѬl۪tm< ۗ~IRUV bA:`&#^H]#_FMq{WGVIAӦ$i{帊:5y#j0b3ِP!EApJbn։l9vl`#YY1_%uB4FS7:{N{6C:D=u!/Z| bĪ=Ua5Q&jlӄa)hΠݝSvahL&lf6z$h0VRbOׅ^JswPѳUU3<Τ)S\KL~v2+Frh*ͺmWa,7 Q^L/upEo%> 9ę%ƹ& .`$c*' Vَ N%lC_KE#ê ʁܟK^w1qf=?$vmhY$V+?꯭N{TIp啻,VZo>(>ERj28[K GصgΨ$AQ3 WIRvCȶaK< H`ŊVV3l>9])mk-5:!Mx:m.["-mz=!eo!o:lIZD.Ƃ*gИݔF[t 0ɷ<60綷Aa$K_Gwܨ.س:4e+[M;sRriCp@5] k<}u&M~!"|Ie鸢a1ʆFKhW@.Uϲ \W6R?%K'Xʹ>P`4ilSR*EVeOsF͕*'eiJf\=EWcJQ+fV\f$SIhd5/I!9?,X*xc ('.y!aĖe#3I 1IarR\&hͼ刬: MQPfbK[LddI;WiG{xC\g(HS酌A3{ )'8^-ĩD\c%Z !rn0Ǩ^S cBܝ4;X^7{p4Fq;5c# 2eRfO)[Eę#251Pj*٠S Ju+廭& ;-FlWĕlސ[-e+ b"Ft*cw- > 2uu 5pO抲TiTsmҘ^[x#s Y&̒LxE 4NV\3q殮;&J~RĴ}"^|e*LQe KuB\ U{]idsؾ&J7G„l1^ET4T=7~bԶB-:ZH^Zz*:t!U_, ֈ(Mr2MQGkg$sq5:yxx2l/w`vNZslNM5-;B;Ū恞p-9pRMAs锉"5 *\"+MCߺH8uwz "h|zAE{NA:gev,wݖ- : Ac %V$0_L,"` m]JB\5:-w㥺 -2$婢 'g%\L@TtA%_O~$ m: 6: w\@u'8UVfaqr_gmÃ)A T* 8Q\E!Z[ hn7 K wO09&%_Cۚ%#4sUb.˰NQv[AwT}akԫẌ#00Ȝ\u5bfhĜR}:X r(jxZxiAф4e N'6i"džδrU >!Q9y͒QS#=gNۭv!75.;AoyD#Yh f!kD SJ:ǒz'r|huG4s4Ta탎]TMmxd*lt)7cb빱&3 Mq`c1R>?@!1˽^ؒ:*YF0OV̙7$aAod^AC4#P%ޓ? 8^ 7l&d4vRW$ґܙQ q5+ ^\:YQ^ȫh؛ĶoFTg\ank=ð}nr~JM$}~OVt)QGχhi>~" A(u)6M;QM 7.ꈲu)^~_E]! U=%njK5Y4+ mY6 YܲZް=oCƄ? +K _? @[PqiA*> iV$(n&T!3]KFa=׶UQ4M<צ*{˞2oXj(6/Uk<6WMDMԉ68V;iKyWb_6zXѽF#"׿fG6`ġ Y^GiHTHab1v ]bMrێ+is CJ|!9g~GQ br;Hòt.`iTY$sn(j @*t؀Ah$)G;+2SV.`'L"u ^̔™cm@GrmV,=( nnBiS៳[5sZƜY$6uAMͻ` Z}q E-^}uԋ'KC$ũ5S,#+ %_$1rEt(w@2֤=~!3R,t83Sl-9_훖Ů /hX-OAXͻs,Q1 M*xi;j.h4[#}VCGB6Ρ(ۄo!!a~Uf̭wqtd\lgxgu8A6 -/U4[B9Ƣ  *VU$Uzj&p"֍b%ИtFmRjK2!Ք[ۊݹHhgMN^& PUI ÃMj(R'QDxv1VmOp D(27)u"h<+ƴ+ƺ&Y͚,d}`9,ԬPo>3YQ?(4}5YsfAux@{X g^{CLU/3hqhTUQT $\QrcLnGPX^9QHǰ XR`?/AMq ӱA+a0 6V'#?*a$Q|0 Yy}ӶFXLJ9xG\jc+o F?B+FTc]qqPEfw/kppmc-I.tș//er)Ƅe#TuPTH%IQ e KЪٜ򰏗9>m“k=5-Rz.C'uh#Ȝu1@iP ~RA,*aTD ޒL"TT- q_j1\-ՎUxg쥙B"D\1U\+W$i(9jCJ8jin$>Ye?Z2qN7C<ʩ( l=r%CmnR%Qp16NM ̒@ rT𢀎87ՠ' -h{D2~ՑP o5*J_ƕ$#*"F*+@uq( mN ? yasY2on)b]TUaeI day|#4wҌjH{ˈ+ey(Ec;mh Yo>+xqg*Ag-zq-Fܜ&}g QǓb: $ΣBptPdacUǙr llWr`3j̞hR-;Qn9hOwēW닷\)A{+]wQۓ苵IֺeVߵZ7}n{q݂ ?gg?$ nw2O5?|͝' XP `H$B/;Y^ᠰtF壯3Ue) R6$bZ]vssSGS C><B a[͎W߯@)Q"K=Q.3AT}y3GLG-=&r_r3E-#N%Dd_3'`i1XZli{A;EuЦ{/Ex|84<k=2/m WnQeAqX V^YrH|F)(yXh,䍿4;jʸ~zv}}=n]GA81-ߝ:9Nq,(l '" Lᨏtp{W5GphpR`V!:[EZn&$E}of5EfctVBݞjaF` XӌM .*`uȻk(=7*ю!Gތ(BlLYٺwDpN{ѣ4fB{Yۧ8%[83C_|n+W3pAI FGSpT%DUog H!٫ ͱ| Ap\N偦Okm0 DcrFݴQU}۶&e.(~[~#qod:Z^:k"uJ;4%;5'_b.gHG8k"]NnV& ƟI`&Z@a4 l_rY؞~l^%ڊm/ݪ >wwmMG.Ѫ]?$wM(?idAdK(L^64lRna}]mph߉pT?XhVQ2]}G"/_p6&9&o}j,Uh:5cВ>{ם됑C(M{/hĬ&{{Oqę2uGI3Ilwdq xgw^'G+ԽV2Bة 3oz'6QzX!,O,Se1& F; v}0x}"dՓV@̈́ U.fQU t2\C=Dj*zɽ0b2Hc.3Nʳk}œj6 [-$1+\e/v%a%qAuW좶鴴צhm{\9f|8LhQxn-4lڻ \Yŏ-eyEr89FFn;;͜hWVAϹ'k8r(R(<ч2TE~;Ǖ?,ꨈΣ)$X塓mϕϹ϶7ld="y_d1G7Cŗe%EͰ^51l$-$= ֛[!W%b(Pc?  (iH@GC-$DALx(raK WwPœ>r̓%Carb=76xj9AI"*UwVKiɋ2hA4,V~(zp:rco읬NZu␔S aC]w #7e#j/vX fîi =qUYD݈;I9q u ;E)gb tu,8͢s_R⛃8ltc*2yl!|1rq=n}@{ϸe"4 F\5YД\!TCQx'%}œl 3e>Td|ZƕTQA%B1:#ڡæ£ 1m .< (ne<[9%)= =Aɮ&V\.r9D+@h)q &BYuf6 _r*D?fJ|lEO*+R(ϖQhy3:F"ϟuKD.ע@_KU-y`\) ėd#fTlI%3zW'zˑCҚ<55B8j-mn:&vsFY ޻'>i&?/.n x$9>bZ `2S5W$FS+eKw/7XM}K@" +7XOIɢvᄑ_XrXJċ> a/,,Ę.Ki$sƑQګP%Ua~(7iʵ5FUɥ]M8*$"4yy ƀh<عcoqGo#Xmx8H?զ#J5XӨޣE"fxJ I/ -'GV. V`Ae*1(43*D+ ^ovm1P߇E,c>@ #.t`=*^P*( ],Tҙ~hHoz- @a TܮNtwb29 5L|{.A&(èuq2'w1B2%O;P I5J]r.QTmSWPaO*]x̯ׄ)Nä]XPqލlW=Q)}_ΎW':i쮺FV=+U?IC%B#- ;Ljg*Zδ|׮IO'0 L.#$5hۨhTи>j~5 ԥdh&gjMM[]ϧܯ?g?m^5ɴ.&фX~Ow^5{#FTQGv+ͺCX #cpŹbom,Ej"}wM|&/QuA߇W` -Y°' #@14y?GsϵބڳcJ%Ox&:<]&ge3F&{j8_گ)68ya @i|tn)#,\X\7ᨒŪIr$a9mr0}36^VwDz Q}a,)[NBJ]}F,],F0&UsN5h_Dj%wufD9kygX(:LOoձLXuE,G=m6avo8#UAϺӍo=7g~]u,0rG* \fExyu|$i,ˏư#$ ,7iMr4Q~G2ϏڲY UP =P. A:7āO6'|Q\ Ļr۵ߜ*u:ɽ(M;~}6}#IeEtM,{rl*j^ydYH􎓄G: =hUl1CJa/|H*h]psӮ\5k:v76PޖEQ*.hB_#W4?~;e>0?s?ÿoVw?Q OēOz&ckx26qfxA`!h0-Gg+nE };TۥXNBW$y8jrl}$u﬊eNGeb G3IcND2^N8ƚ:;2q:Ɔcщ25`i֍s]?0|Dt4X #sܭMJK|/X\]pc87 cAh]:ǣ=j3SrIw2蚿4hK|OqgߧQu.Nt궢÷ f<`:ZI #gBLtpޤvv=T\DbO];Zfz؁=fuB#f[k qq *`״g'e'DA x>ܖ\&XzYE^JÝ2[}^vt˷.ޚWx˽S)\o1|Qq|pM< fAz/X`~7^'yX;ALCa.;nKB,K-+WI|U''jV1lHiJ}iod䐕xgm$jך) pw 8xH!7!z"} 7m$tWt7GwK Ƭhh#+ `lW E IEYĞwUŗEw04483)1qCbɂٔ9)3&%*?@u! bS|\d ӾVCBiJK̻ZO?ȹ)8|qQGY)"]m^0(1mz=|A;qW=UX'?_uyR'yr9@r*bJ\ $k:S?A NKOCP<4Dz$ }&t '(e-6H͎3Uq]E؂0YG)<O"$06O{ բlb;s#;!.&*Dd@U2H1c jOEmsdVK|N1R=Z)TOHC*o$/,nw7{dp Vgo (+?V&J}j qz)B2yѸ)=f]7@`E.'aV_:{z 4-h,wۭW-ZĴev9 ,?!&jKM8]ODOY68N1EF?6!*̔șZTK@Ĺp(JFL91c "̓g\t'X() V] PC9tݼ6\)k9!՝tnp?o<|&5pUZ7,MtAfOts=mJ0^?+" %mysnad`۠* ,aX$(P`UV۹{ˁMaPԴi0;q#=RF{ .N&F8 ^žkHΛiM?4" [! ӝ#nl&~IĭMn#\_3+ݱc iP$4}:A2Z̟TXYMyx@_U22ݽR>ϙ[H:IbZUETz+ /( ߚ֑]0eDl-Wg/DdqA>s9s.50 2n,Iz,w. 3mFd"+M$C x=zy+ %=ѨF9Wgp9٧%Wk`t).7y>7mXZr{Q]ă6khhM-r|euDqH(I#(aKΰ!E5MA$`EeX/;K@L1 F]ajĹ50#7N%s6G膆y% G r# (Aȑ?ގ+^R1pI(B|߯J:qpH.:MN LZτ fu]\\86$ SiX!;t$ۀ#ʻ>9턆]dZ[ET.)v,TnSmuƲtbo> 䔐gnʂ\(T$\Ύ"̥9y+@#j2B @ @?r zNNM̟'"xK!E_x"&r %z>=ii=wT!MOX8ѱ]F`f뤭bu]9f6#t 3bFpmd}b}(XJ4T &'y=CkǒNI8_<`yOA?d)ƂG0,g1Cb46'^Q_cD"AL?Lm Q_ rB ;"`}zv GHT;{DRo4k@!%&~(ٽPpnPWimH\NS5 I64 KL 8&TЁ2ZEe L,79ҔStJj$wwjXUÉ@=Ik×Asp-œ0QGH{#td9$ 1QQ$rlYlݼ͸^CYgAJWhqn\<:t;jƝjFAȑ[ˏ:)\҇]1W=gvKtF:Ərr"hx4xx:?܀>4"Mr]*m  fw+lUhmnVY`Lً> \c\d*Փ~ш] Wإq$_~ 㸩߈j!c.j'M24z2%A(7]| p%E=A80ؓ<|X F\Kx×tfL6)N׍;&JհYrsg!dIt@1h6fy4* >d&^>N\ݑL ܤ9E! c1 *K3LR{*by*xch*9LBF#_%4SORN.9>]qER[QЛ5vJ3tN2c5.c*E V$RH318msu6~Y0)pQ'/9g̑"jX dʇh^گhC=s}q WZ "@*Zu.c8$K g[RT>N4"WΈ0n񨟭xIc/_ܲ)ِ}JdqFpȉrqTT刑 |Fi|P"{y9 x{,KʜS+JLz~!$U׷$ξƮדtj _Lw?ϧX?q%A>P\h5_ 5(\7LCݙbUZPDEԱg g8i/& 7(F,Jy7̛h{M==[fj]cW.,;Qdy(QWWI&  vên(sl*&ɥ0&fLljiɹ^S^ʱ"ar{$񱓫x?b寜j+^ל1vVHiQh•7x-Cfz3#0 ay-ًb5%j{~iI꭛T Y"KAFB;w{*lh Ā^y&Ci 3ɺ~J”1?pH9]\?mٽm~ّ̟»QǟK/ycY;?L 5pnIwZa!y<9q62P4l椢H@ y!N|%J4u] ǃ5buW}YL8Ae!|5`x|g|F(QDmpq氫D ǖj&ű𠕹LŸɣrV I26#aC$"L%C(1't4yRݰg<))-1rځt>Ix}fSz$b㥶A_W[6ꠙZDzri YJ^/B+R!`d! r+SmKiI'$\qW9ѮM8ّP IXƿծ:Zi/giM;d5LF6M*(ޤQ~!x8uY+Ce筳uv.7z8TwX \p;4i!G+slN@S~h'isumy7u1զ:Ϲ6|OfѮ=7k:!^z20Ob]+Ȣ L VKHEЩp:Ri$ȇ^8Ṧg\/_l~C]퐈믆tڽ+3f3p xFm<-qwY㫵O0ZYwG%w6VV'@$l4 ٟ8'={e`h\=.ԮxG\\73PeWNB v_‡ b NʘvJ ۭ$mAuj=C,{HcB.N٪N<@Y;[gv<[1~zI"ey"Kkm3 H[j؝=SMx'q NETth0" èdAI8CplRaX[]b-xlV@}rIO<);} h SC – Real Estate Developers : Cannot compel homebuyers to be bound by one-sided agreement. | AK GROUP

The Supreme Court on January 12 observed that a real estate developer cannot compel homebuyers to be bound by one-sided contractual terms contained in the Apartment Buyer’s Agreement. The apex court held that incorporation of such unreasonable clauses in the agreement constitutes an unfair trade practice under the Consumer Protection Act.

“The terms of the Apartment Buyer‘s Agreement are oppressive and wholly one-sided, and would constitute an unfair trade practice under the Consumer Protection Act, 1986,” the Supreme Court has said, adding, “In view of the above, we hold that the developer cannot compel the apartment buyers to be bound by the one-sided contractual terms contained in the Apartment Buyer‘s Agreement.”

On the issue of whether provisions of RERA be given primacy over Consumer Protection Act, 1986, the court was of the view that in case there are two concurrent remedies available, and the aggrieved party chooses to exercise one, then “he loses the right to simultaneously exercise the other for the same cause of action.”

The bench comprising Justices DY Chandrachud, Indu Malhotra and Indira Banerjee  held this while disposing of an appeal filed by a real estate developer Ireo Grace Realtech against an order passed by National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission. The NCDRC order had directed Ireo Grace to refund the amount paid by homebuyers on account of the inordinate delay in completing the construction and obtaining the occupation certificate.

The court directed that the amounts deposited by the apartment buyers be refunded with 9 percent simple interest per annum from November 27, 2018, till the date of payment of the entire amount. The refund will be paid within a period of three months from the date of this judgment. If there is any further delay, the developer will be liable to pay default interest at 12 percent simple interest per annum.

The court also directed the developer not to deduct the earnest money of 20 percent from the principal amount, or any other amount on account of the various defaults committed by the developer, including the delay of over seven months in obtaining the Fire NOC (No Objection Certificate).

There were four issues that were raised in the appeal before the court. These were to do with determining the date from which the 42 months period for handing over possession is to be calculated under Clause 13.3, whether it would be from the date of issuance of the Fire NOC as contended by the developer; or, from the date of sanction of the building plans, as contended by the apartment buyers.

Whether the terms of the apartment buyers’ agreement were one-sided, and the Apartment Buyers would not be 

bound by the same.

Whether the provisions of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 must be given primacy over the Consumer Protection Act, 1986

Whether on account of the inordinate delay in handing over possession, the apartment buyers were entitled to terminate the agreement, and claim refund of the amounts deposited with interest.

In this case, real estate developer Ireo had filed an appeal before the Supreme Court to challenge the judgment passed by the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission  directing refund of the amounts deposited by the apartment buyers in its project called The Corridors being developed in Sector 67-A, Gurgaon, Haryana, on account of the inordinate delay in completing the construction and obtaining the occupation certificate.

Homebuyers had filed a case in the National Commission, wherein they appealed for the developer to be directed to refund the amount of Rs.14,472,364 paid by the Apartment Buyer along with interest at 20 percent per annum compounded quarterly till realisation, and compensation towards damages on account of harassment, mental agony and litigation charges.

The court concluded that the 42 months’ period in Clause 13.3 of the Agreement for handing over possession of the apartments would be required to be computed from the date on which Fire NOC was issued, and not from the date of the Building Plans being sanctioned. In this particular matter, there was a delay of approximately seven months in obtaining the Fire NOC by the developer.

Terms of the Apartment Buyers’ Agreement one-sided, and buyers would not be bound by the same 

The court also observed that there were several clauses in the agreement that “reflect the wholly one-sided terms of the Apartment Buyer‘s Agreement, which are entirely loaded in favour of the Developer, and against the allottee at every step. The terms of the Apartment Buyer‘s Agreement are oppressive and wholly one-sided, and would constitute an unfair trade practice under the Consumer Protection Act, 1986,” it said.

The court said the analysis of the Agreement revealed that under the construction-linked plan, Clause 6 provided that the apartment buyers would be required to deposit 20 percent of the sale consideration within 45 days of booking of the apartment. Clause 7.4 of the Agreement provides that if there is a delay in payment of an instalment, the apartment buyer would be required to pay Interest on every delayed payment of such instalment at 20 percent simple interest per annum.

Should provisions of RERA be given primacy over Consumer Protection Act, 1986?

The Consumer Protection Act, 1986 was enacted to protect the interests of consumers, and provide a remedy for better protection of the interests of consumers, including the right to seek redressal against unfair trade practices or unscrupulous exploitation, the court said.

“An allottee may elect or opt for one out of the remedies provided by law for redressal of its injury or grievance. An election of remedies arises when two concurrent remedies are available, and the aggrieved party chooses to exercise one, in which event he loses the right to simultaneously exercise the other for the same cause of action,” the court said.

The Supreme Court also looked into the aspect of whether on account of the inordinate delay in handing over possession, the apartment buyers were entitled to terminate the agreement, and claim a refund of the amounts deposited with interest.

Stating that it is cognizant of the prevailing market conditions as a result of Covid–19 pandemic, which have greatly impacted the construction industry.

“In these circumstances, it is necessary to balance the competing interest of both parties,” the court said.

Legal experts have welcomed the order.

“In this order, the Supreme Court has rightly dismissed the plea of the builder that after enactment of RERA a homebuyer cannot approach the consumer forum for redressal of his grievance. The Supreme Court has clarified that aggrieved buyers have the right to choose either of the remedies available to them – consumer court or RERA. While they may have to choose one remedy, the fact remains that they do have the option to which one to go with,” explains advocate Aditya Parolia of PSP Legal, who represented homebuyers in this case.

The SC has also clarified that it is only a simultaneous invocation that will be barred which implies that one may withdraw from one remedy and choose another at any given point of time, he said.“The Supreme Court has upheld the National Commission’s earlier position that one-sided clauses in builder buyer agreements are unfair, and where it is established that there has been a deficiency in service by a builder, a refund is inevitable. Once again, the Supreme Court has focused on the welfare of the homebuyers in the event of inordinate delays by the developer. It is worth mentioning that not only has refund been provided to buyers, but even the earnest money has to be returned in its entirety without any deductions,” said Yudhisht Singh, senior partner, YNS & Associates.

Source: https://www.moneycontrol.com/news/business/real-estate/sc-says-real-estate-developers-cannot-compel-homebuyers-to-be-bound-by-one-sided-agreements-6336651.html